As the old saying goes , “ men are trash . ” If you ’re a twenty - something cleaning woman , you ’ve probably say this phrase to your friends at least once , mayhap over alcoholic drinks after a military personnel has done something defective . Or perhaps you ’ve said it to coworkers after your dumb boss makes a dumbbell joke in front of the entire fellowship .
manifestly , however , sharing that opinion on Facebook is a no - no . In fact , doing so can get your content remove , or even get you banned from post for a flow of time .
Phyllis Meehan , a 29 - class - old corporate administrator exist in San Francisco , distinguish Gizmodo she changed her cover photo to an image that featured the idiom on Monday evening . On Tuesday evening , she said , she went back on Facebook — only to take in a message sound out Facebook had transfer the image , and that she was blocked from posting for 24 hour .
The range of a function itself originated with Erin La Ninfa , who create it a few weeks ago usingCanva , an on-line graphic design software . She has a website , “ Just Another White Hoe , ” where she hosts a few of these kinds of picture — theclassicgenreof saccharine , Pinterest - panache inspirational images subverted with messages like “ Happy Golden Shower . ” She originally share it in a secret group ( she would n’t disclose which one ) , and said women in the radical shared it from there . As she explicate to Gizmodo , “ patently not all men are trash , however , the ones who are really upset about it are the ones who perfectly are . ”
Then , she said , a couple of days later , she was secernate she was blocked for three days for send a screenshot of “ some sexist bullshit a man said ” on Facebook with the legend “ men are trash . ”
Meehan tell she had “ no thought ” if any of her Quaker report her . But several of Phyllis ’ friends told Gizmodo that they , too , had posted the original “ men are rubbish ” meme , only to have it removed by Facebook .
Chad Lavimoniere , a UX designer at a startup in New York , said that after Meehan ’s cover song photo C. W. Post was removed , he posted the image with the following schoolbook : “ A ally of mine got reported / blocked from Facebook for 24 hours for post this meme . Who are the fragile snowbird , again ? ” That billet , too , was necessitate down .
Another acquaintance of Meehan ’s , Kayla Ceretti , recount Gizmodo she posted the image and had it removed . And a third friend , Lily Leach , who is presently experience in the Middle East , had the same experience . Lily say Gizmodo she “ shared the ‘ gentleman’s gentleman are Trash ’ meme and write this legend : ‘ My friend Phyllis got ban from FB for 24 hour for sharing this . Where is the lie ? ’ ” She , like Kayla , tagged Phyllis in the office . Then , less than 24 hours later , she said she “ was notified it has been reported and take down . ” ( A stick to up post complaining about the meme ’s removal was not remove . )
It seems clear that Phyllis — and maybe Lily , Chad , and Kayla — had some Facebook friends who reported their office as nauseous . ( I posted both the school text “ men are trash ” and the image on my Facebook yesterday , and none of my friends have report me . ) But that still does n’t explain why Facebook would call up the image or its subject matter were deserving remove — and go so far as to ban user from posting altogether .
When we reached out to Facebook , we stupefy an answer : The companionship say that , under its guidelines , the posts fell under the category of hatred speech ; it would only allow such posts when it had enough linguistic context to know it was meant as humor , or was being used ego - referentially . So it ’s passably clear : Facebook considers the phrase “ humans are chicken feed ” hatred speech .
Facebook’sguidelinesban detest language that “ flat snipe the great unwashed based on their slipstream , ethnicity , internal beginning , religious tie-up , sexual preference , sex , gender , or gender identity , or , serious disabilities or diseases . ” The guideline also “ allow humor , sarcasm or social comment related to these topics , and we consider that when people expend their authentic identity , they are more creditworthy when they partake this kind of comment . ”
As all four of the affected posters aim out , much worse stuff remain up all the meter .
Facebook clear has — and has had for a while — a trouble with depicted object moderation . It ’s been criticized for removing apostabout the Orlando shooting , and amemeabout Brock Turner ( which was later bushel ) . And on the other end of the spectrum , it ’s been criticize for not removingracist content ; in Germany , government minister have pressured Facebook to roleplay more pro - actively to removeracistcontent . It ’s also received literary criticism for not acting quickly enough to dispatch graphic substance , like a graphicphotoof a murdered woman or late murdersbroadcaston Facebook live .
More to the point in time : “ men are trash ” is not hate speech . for the most part , men who roleplay offend by things like “ men are trash ” or “ bloodless people suck ” are doing it to make a gunpoint , not because they really are offended ; they seem to cogitate being offended by a slur is a sport activity they ’re being left out of .
But I ’m sorry , dudes : that just is n’t how it works . “ Men are trash ” is simply not the same affair as sexist attacks on women , because you do n’t front the systemic subjugation that make sexist slur so toxic . If you ’re a man and someone calls you a stupid shabu man , wow , I ’m sorry you had a bad day . If someone foretell a fair sex a bitch or a slut , that ’s tinged with millennia of oppression .
Facebook acting like these are all the same matter — to put “ men are trash ” in the same category of speech as slurs — shows that , yet again , it just does n’t get it .
Facebooksexism
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , redeem to your present .
Please select your desired newssheet and submit your email to kick upstairs your inbox .
You May Also Like
